In my opinion, this is the toughest choice so far in the tournament. Hard to believe we already got the ultimate MILF match-up in Round Two with Robin Vs Scarlett!

Robin from Halloween Switch
Scarlett from Different Perspectives
Round Two: Match 7 - Robin Vs Scarlett
- Robin (58%, 273 Votes)
- Scarlett (42%, 198 Votes)
Total Voters: 471
Yesterday’s Match Results:
The Quarter-Finalists in the Eastern Conference are set with Alyssa, Caroline, Jamie, and Zoey. Now all that’s left is to decide the final two slots in the West.
[tabs] [tab title=”SF Beyond Results”]




My vote for momma Young, no doubt
wow, im surprised to see robin winning
It’s not too surprising. Robin is just as hot as Scarlett. Plus she fits more in line with this website by being a man-turned-woman. That certainly gives Robin an edge over Scarlett. Plus, Halloween Switch is one of the best stories on this website.
Hardest choice thus far.
Scarlett will always be my choice… gaaah why is it getting harder. Next round will be nearly impossible. I just have to remember you can’t spell impossible without possible. It’ll come to me when I’m ready.
Scarlett. The OG milf. If the beyond series of her didnt sway you.. i dont know what else to tell ya
Robin also had a Beyond series. At I’d say that Robin was even hotter in that series than Scarlett was in Substitute Perspectives.
I voted for robin because she was a gender change scarlet is just a good looking mom who has had people turn into her.
I’m not sure, and you’re right, but she is also a role model for some, such as Holly & Ashley, also her son Chris has, so to speak, copied a lot from her, or learned from her, without her knowing probably at least so far.
It the most challenging one yet. And we had a beyond scene between them both. Which didnt make it easier
This is the toughest one so far!!
Damn!!! If Scarlett wins, she goes against Jazmin!!!
If so, it’ll be Jazmin, hands down.
No, I don’t think that would happen at all. Regardless of who wins this match, the winner will bury Jazmin in the quarterfinals. I don’t think Jazmin stands a chance against either Robin or Scarlett.
Tell that to Mariah.
Mariah against the Moms… That would be tough
From me at this time it looks like Robin is going to win.